Disclaimer: The Author owns both BibleWorks 8 and Logos 4 Platinum. Various specs and prices come directly from the respective websites.
BibleWorks http://www.bibleworks.com
Logos http://www.logos.com
Pricing:
BibleWorks: Full DVD Version $349, Qualified group rate $250 (offered by the CSL Bookstore in the Fall Quarter) Note: BibleWorks 9 has just been released.
Logos: Full Version Varies based on the package chosen
Christian Home – Christian Home Library gives you everything you need to study what the Bible says about marriage, prayer, faith, parenting, home school, devotions, and so much more! Christian Home Library comes over 80 Bibles and Bible reference books worth over $1,300.00 in print. $149.95
Bible Study Library – Bible Study Library gives you the tools you need to dig deep into Scripture, with almost 275 books worth almost $4,500.00 in print! $264.95
Leader’s Library – Leader’s Library is a comprehensive set of books and tools available for busy pastors and church leaders, with almost 350 books worth over $5,000.00 in print! $324.95
Original Languages – Original Languages Library is a complete library of Greek, Hebrew, Aramaic, Syriac, Latin, and English resources for advanced biblical research, with over 300 books, grammars, lexicons, and more worth over $4,500.00 in print! $415.95
Scholar’s Library – Our bestselling library just got better! Scholar’s Library is newly expanded for Logos Bible Software 4, with over 475 books and commentaries worth almost $8,000.00 in print-an incredible value! $629.95
Scholar’s Silver – Scholar’s Library: Silver is a massive library for serious pastors and scholars, with almost 775 books worth over $11,000.00 in print! $999.95
Scholar’s Gold – Scholar’s Library: Gold is a massive library for serious students and scholars of the Bible, with 950 books worth almost $15,000.00 in print! $1,379.95
Scholar’s Platinum – Put an entire bookcase of theological and biblical resources at your fingertips. Scholar’s Library: Platinum is a massive electronic library for serious scholars, with more than 1,200 books worth nearly $19,000.00 in print. $1,689.95
Portfolio – Logos Bible Software 4: Portfolio Edition represents a major milestone in the publication of biblical and theological reference books, with almost 1,650 books worth more than $31,000.00 in print! $4,290.00
System Requirements:
BibleWorks (http://www.bibleworks.com/content/sys-req.html)
- Windows® XP/Vista/7 (Mac users require additional virtualization software such as Parallels, Fusion, VirtualBox, or Boot Camp. Mac and Linux users, please see below)
- Minimum 1024×600 display
- Minimum 512 MB RAM
- 1 GB hard drive space free (15 GB for full install)
- DVD drive
- Internet Explorer® version 7
- Internet connection for updates
Logos (http://www.logos.com/support/techfaq)
The minimum requirements for running Logos 4 on a PC are:
- Pentium 4 1 GHz (or AMD equivalent- 1.3 GHz or higher)
- 1 GB RAM (2GB for Windows 7 & Vista)
- Windows XP SP3
- DVD drive
- 12 GB hard drive space on local drive (May require additional space depending on your library).
- 1024X600 Display
- 256 MB DirectX 9 graphics device
- Internet connection required for activation & updates
The recommended requirements for running Logos 4 on a PC are:
- Core 2 Duo 2 GHz
- 3GB+ RAM
- Windows Vista or Windows 7
- DVD drive
- 1280X1024 display
- 512MB DirectX10 graphics device with WDDM 1.0 or higher driver
- 20 GB hard drive space on local drive (May require additional space depending on your library).
- Broadband internet connection
The minimum requirements for running Logos 4 on a Mac
- Mac OS X 10.5
- Intel only (PowerPC not supported)
- 2GB RAM
- 12 GB hard drive space on local drive (May require additional space depending on your library).
- DVD-ROM
The recommended requirements for running Logos 4 on a Mac
- Mac OS X 10.6
- Core 2 Duo 2 GHz
- 4GB RAM
- 20 GB hard drive space on local drive (May require additional space depending on your library).
- DVD-ROM
Note: Logos 4 base packages can be downloaded immediately after purchase. Here are the download sizes for each of our collections:
- Christian Home Library: 450 MB
- Bible Study Library: 4.65 GB
- Leader’s Library: 4.68 GB
- Original Languages Library: 3.81 GB
- Scholar’s Library: 6.06 GB
- Scholar’s Library: Silver: 6.60 GB
- Scholar’s Library: Gold: 6.97 GB
- Scholar’s Library: Platinum: 7.28 GB
- Logos Bible Software 4: Portfolio Edition: 8.05 GB
- Note: Logos 4 will require more space than listed above if you have existing books in the Libronix format. Actual download sizes will vary by user.
Resources
Logos has digitized thousands of dollars-worth of print books consisting of millions of pages that fit nicely onto your laptop. BibleWorks has made language, diagram, and exegetical work so quick and easy that one is able to wrestle with the text itself longer before reading what others have said about it. Logos is always adding new products to their ever expanding library. They also run sales from time to time and offer what they call pre-pub sales in which you can purchase new titles for a much cheaper price than what the product will regularly run. BibleWorks only offers a handful of add-ins because their subject matter is much smaller than that of Logos.
If you compare the add-ins that they have in common, the base price is cheaper at BibleWorks. If you factor in the CSL discount (ask IT) on Logos, then they are almost dead even. Head-to-head, I would give the advantage to Logos because of the wider audience that they appeal to and the quantitatively more add-ins overall.
Bible/Word Study
Logos has similar functions in terms of exegesis and bible study tools that BibleWorks has. Logos certainly has more study tools about the bible than BibleWorks. However, I personally believe that if one is studying the Bible, he or she should wrestle more with the text rather than seek another’s understanding of what the Bible is saying. BibleWorks is much more equipped for intense Bible study than Logos.
Usability
At first, Bibleworks 8 is difficult to use and Logos is pretty much ready to go. However, there is a learning curve to both. This again boils down to what you want and are looking for in Bible Software. I would give the early advantage to Logos and the learned advantage to BibleWorks.
Strengths and Weaknesses
BibleWorks 8
BibleWorks is strong in terms of the original language resources that come as part of its base package. It contains, for example, the Juoun-Muraoka Hebrew Grammar, the Waltke and O’Connor Hebrew Syntax, and the Wallace Greek Grammar as part of its base package. The optional add-on modules available from BibleWorks are all related to original language research. BibleWorks is a no-frills program, and this no-frills approach makes it affordable. BibleWorks has an incredibly fast response time. It does searches of the biblical texts in milliseconds and gives you instant information from lexicons and grammars. In my opinion, it can’t be touched in terms of speed of access to lots of exegetical data.
The main weakness of BibleWorks is that it does not come in a Mac version. However, it can be run on a Mac by using software such as Parallels Desktop, but ideally, it could be offered in both a PC and Mac version. BibleWorks also does not yet have the syntax search capabilities available on Logos. The format for BibleWorks resources is poor. You cannot mark them up or take notes in them. BibleWorks has a lot of great resources, but they are very limited in what they offer in terms of types and number of resources. They have stepped it up recently, but are still far from being in the same league as Logos. I love having hundreds of commentaries as electronic resources. I use them daily.
Logos 4
Logos’s resources are great and enable you to do about as much to them as you can to your own print books—and more. You can underline, highlight in lots of different colors, and apply a limitless number of markups. You can also add notes within the resources. In addition, you can change the font and font size for easier reading. Logos is also the only program that currently has any kind of syntax search capability for the original languages. The Logos interface is one of the most intuitive of the two. It resembles a basic website interface. The amount and kind of resources is very helpful. To be able to do a search and see results in original language resources, commentaries, sermon illustration books, etc. is a strong point. There are between 6000 and 7000+ resources available for Logos (The number actually grows daily). Logos cannot be touched in terms of the sheer amount of great resources that they offer. There’s no real alternative for one interested in building a primarily digital library. The syntax tools are great. They are going to significantly change the study of the original language texts—both (1) in what they can do that couldn’t be done before and (2) in saving time doing more efficiently what could be done before only very inefficiently.
The one of the main weaknesses of Logos is the cost. Even with the available discounts, the high price could be out of the reach of many pastors and seminary students who are trying to make ends meet. Some of which is being combated by offering payment plans. The other weakness of Logos is a byproduct of one of its strengths – namely the large number of resources. In the first place, most users will probably find a large number of these resources to be extraneous. Second, the large number of resources slows down searches – sometimes dramatically. Another weakness is speed, but this is only due to the vast amount of resources included with each package.
Recommendations:
For the seminarian or pastor who is using a PC, I would recommend investing long term in Logos. It has all of the tools of BibleWorks with the added benefit of commentaries, word studies, and research resources. My next follow up blog will include some of the resources that may be of assistance for LCMS parishioners, teachers, deaconesses, seminarians, and pastors.








Electronic Resources for the Seminarian
July 23, 2011If you are a Logos owner, this is specifically for you. I am not a fan of carrying a ton of books around to class or on trips. I also like the ability to study no matter where I am and this is possible with these resources via Logos through Concordia Publishing House (CPH).
Concordia Commentaries – Digital Editions
Leviticus: Dr. John Kleinig
Joshua: Prof. Adolph Harstad
Ruth: Dr. John Wilch
Proverbs: Dr. Andrew Steinmann
The Song of Songs: Dr. Christopher Mitchell
Ezekiel 1-20 & 21-48: Dr. Horace Hummel
Daniel: Dr. Andrew Steinmann
Amos: Dr. R. Reed Lessing
Jonah: Dr. R. Reed Lessing
Matthew 1-11:1: Dr. Jeffrey Gibbs
Luke 1:1-9:50 & 9:51-24:53: Dr. Arthur A. Just
1 Corinthians: Dr. Gregory Lockwood
Colossians: Dr. Paul Deterding
Philemon: Dr. John Nordling
Revelation: Dr. Louis Brighton
Note: Currently awaiting the arrival of following (HINT):
Ezra-Nehemiah: Dr. Andrew Steinmann
Ecclesiastes: Dr. James Bollhagen
Matthew 11:2-20:34: Dr. Jeffrey Gibbs
Concordia Electronic Theological Library - Note: Including classes that these texts are used in…
The Basic Scriptural Study Collection
Share this:
Like this:
Tags:1 Corinthians, Amos, Book of Concord, Colossians, Concordia Commentary, Concordia Electronic Theological Library, Concordia: The Lutheran Confessions, CPH, Daniel, Ezekiel 1-20 & 21-48, Jonah, Joshua, Leviticus, Logos, Luke 1:1-9:50 & 9:51-24:53, Luther's Works on CD-ROM, Matthew 1-11:1, Philemon, Proverbs, Revelation, Ruth, The Lutheran Study BIble, The Song of Songs
Posted in 1 Corinthians, Amos, Book of Concord, Colossians, Colossians, Concordia Electronic Theological LIbrary, Concordia: The Lutheran Confessions, CPH, Daniel, Ezekiel, Jonah, Joshua, Leviticus, Logos, Luke 1:1-9:50, Luke 9:51-24:53, Luther's Works on CD-ROM, Matthew 1-11:1, Philemon, Proverbs, Revelation, Ruth, The Lutheran Study Bible, The Song of Songs | 3 Comments »